Head-to-head

NordicTrack S22i vs Peloton Bike+ vs Schwinn IC4

NordicTrack S22i

9.1 $1,999

Peloton Bike+

9.4 $2,495

Schwinn IC4

9.2 $999

Verdict

NordicTrack S22i

For riders who find indoor cycling boring. The frame physically tilts -10% to +20% and auto-adjusts resistance to match iFit's scenic routes, so a climb feels real, and the screen rotates for off-bike work. It needs the ~$39/mo iFit, but for immersion it stands alone here.

Peloton Bike+

The bike to buy if classes keep you riding. The deepest instructor library anywhere, Auto-Follow that matches resistance to the class, and a screen that rotates for off-bike strength. It's pricey and needs the ~$44/mo membership, but for class motivation nothing's this immersive.

Schwinn IC4

The smart-money cycling bike. A heavy flywheel and 100 magnetic levels give a smooth, quiet, studio-quality ride, and Bluetooth pairs with Peloton, Zwift, or free YouTube on your tablet. The console is basic, but for a flexible, no-subscription bike, it's the sweet spot.

Best for

NordicTrack S22i

Riders who want scenic, trainer-led rides where the bike auto-adjusts resistance and physically inclines and declines to match the terrain.

Peloton Bike+

People who want instructor-led classes to keep them consistent, and who'll use the rotating touchscreen for off-bike strength and yoga too.

Schwinn IC4

Value seekers who want a sturdy, quiet indoor cycling bike and the freedom to use Peloton, Zwift, or any app on their own tablet.

Avoid if

NordicTrack S22i

You only want simple steady cardio, or you want to ride any app freely — the iFIT experience is the whole point here, and it's a subscription.

Peloton Bike+

You don't want a recurring subscription, or you ride with your own plan — the Bike+ loses much of its value without the All-Access Membership.

Schwinn IC4

You want a big built-in screen and a turnkey class experience — the IC4 gives you a tablet tray, not a touchscreen, and you bring your own app.

Score breakdown

fit

NordicTrac

9.2

Peloton Bi

9.4

Schwinn IC

9.2

ease

NordicTrac

8.9

Peloton Bi

9.5

Schwinn IC

8.8

value

NordicTrac

8.1

Peloton Bi

7.7

Schwinn IC

9.4

quality

NordicTrac

9.0

Peloton Bi

9.4

Schwinn IC

9.0

Specs

type

Connected studio cycle (incline/decline)

Connected indoor bike (subscription)

Indoor cycling (spin) bike

price

$1,999 (+ ~$199 delivery)

$2,495 (+ ~$250 setup; often $1,995)

$999 (often $799)

screen

22 in HD touchscreen, 360 rotating

24 in HD touchscreen, 360 rotating

—

incline

Powered -10% to +20%; AutoAdjust terrain matching

—

include

Hybrid SPD/toe pedals, 3-lb dumbbells, fan, 30W audio; 350 lb cap

—

flywheel

32 lb inertia-enhanced

38 lb; near-silent belt drive

40 lb perimeter-weighted

platform

iFit (~$39/mo, 1 yr free); 17,000+ workouts, scenic Google Maps rides

—

resistance

24 levels digital magnetic; quiet

100 levels magnetic; Auto-Follow auto-resistance

100 levels magnetic (knob); near-silent belt drive

extras

—

4-speaker audio, front camera, Apple GymKit, USB-C

—

pedals

—

Delta clip-in (cycling shoes required)

Dual-sided SPD + toe cages

subscription

—

All-Access ~$44/mo for classes (not optional in practice)

—

frame

—

Welded steel, 330 lb cap; ~106 lb; 10-yr frame warranty

display

—

3 in LCD; Bluetooth to Peloton/Zwift/JRNY

includes

—

BT heart-rate band, 3-lb dumbbells, dual bottle cages

Buy →Buy →Buy →

	NordicTrack S22i	Peloton Bike+	Schwinn IC4
Score	9.1	9.4	9.2
Price	$1,999	$2,495	$999
Verdict	For riders who find indoor cycling boring. The frame physically tilts -10% to +20% and auto-adjusts resistance to match iFit's scenic routes, so a climb feels real, and the screen rotates for off-bike work. It needs the ~$39/mo iFit, but for immersion it stands alone here.	The bike to buy if classes keep you riding. The deepest instructor library anywhere, Auto-Follow that matches resistance to the class, and a screen that rotates for off-bike strength. It's pricey and needs the ~$44/mo membership, but for class motivation nothing's this immersive.	The smart-money cycling bike. A heavy flywheel and 100 magnetic levels give a smooth, quiet, studio-quality ride, and Bluetooth pairs with Peloton, Zwift, or free YouTube on your tablet. The console is basic, but for a flexible, no-subscription bike, it's the sweet spot.
Best for	Riders who want scenic, trainer-led rides where the bike auto-adjusts resistance and physically inclines and declines to match the terrain.	People who want instructor-led classes to keep them consistent, and who'll use the rotating touchscreen for off-bike strength and yoga too.	Value seekers who want a sturdy, quiet indoor cycling bike and the freedom to use Peloton, Zwift, or any app on their own tablet.
Avoid if	You only want simple steady cardio, or you want to ride any app freely — the iFIT experience is the whole point here, and it's a subscription.	You don't want a recurring subscription, or you ride with your own plan — the Bike+ loses much of its value without the All-Access Membership.	You want a big built-in screen and a turnkey class experience — the IC4 gives you a tablet tray, not a touchscreen, and you bring your own app.
Score breakdown
fit	9.2	9.4	9.2
ease	8.9	9.5	8.8
value	8.1	7.7	9.4
quality	9.0	9.4	9.0
Specs
type	Connected studio cycle (incline/decline)	Connected indoor bike (subscription)	Indoor cycling (spin) bike
price	$1,999 (+ ~$199 delivery)	$2,495 (+ ~$250 setup; often $1,995)	$999 (often $799)
screen	22 in HD touchscreen, 360 rotating	24 in HD touchscreen, 360 rotating	—
incline	Powered -10% to +20%; AutoAdjust terrain matching	—	—
include	Hybrid SPD/toe pedals, 3-lb dumbbells, fan, 30W audio; 350 lb cap	—	—
flywheel	32 lb inertia-enhanced	38 lb; near-silent belt drive	40 lb perimeter-weighted
platform	iFit (~$39/mo, 1 yr free); 17,000+ workouts, scenic Google Maps rides	—	—
resistance	24 levels digital magnetic; quiet	100 levels magnetic; Auto-Follow auto-resistance	100 levels magnetic (knob); near-silent belt drive
extras	—	4-speaker audio, front camera, Apple GymKit, USB-C	—
pedals	—	Delta clip-in (cycling shoes required)	Dual-sided SPD + toe cages
subscription	—	All-Access ~$44/mo for classes (not optional in practice)	—
frame	—	—	Welded steel, 330 lb cap; ~106 lb; 10-yr frame warranty
display	—	—	3 in LCD; Bluetooth to Peloton/Zwift/JRNY
includes	—	—	BT heart-rate band, 3-lb dumbbells, dual bottle cages
	Buy →	Buy →	Buy →

PickGrade may earn a commission from purchases made through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. This never affects our grades. Full disclosure.