Head-to-head

Waterdrop Faucet Filter vs PUR PLUS Faucet Mount Filter vs Culligan FM-25 Faucet Filter

Waterdrop Faucet Filter

8.7 $30

PUR PLUS faucet mount water filter installed on a kitchen faucet

PUR PLUS Faucet Mount Filter

9.4 $35

Culligan FM-25 chrome faucet mount water filter installed on a kitchen faucet

Culligan FM-25 Faucet Filter

8.6 $25

Verdict

Waterdrop Faucet F

The long-life pick. A 320-gallon cartridge lasts about twice as long as most, with among the fastest flow tested and excellent taste reduction. One caveat: it's NSF 42 certified but NOT NSF 53 for lead, so if lead is your concern pick the PUR or Culligan instead.

PUR PLUS Faucet Mo

The safe all-rounder. Most clip-ons only handle taste, but the PUR PLUS is also certified for lead under NSF 53 and clips on tool-free. Cartridges last only 2-3 months and it won't fit pull-down faucets, but for certified taste-and-lead at the tap, it's the default.

Culligan FM-25 Fau

The budget pick that keeps the cert. The cheapest filter here still NSF 53 certified for lead, plus mercury and even cysts like giardia that most faucet filters miss. Flow is slow and there's no indicator, but for certified lead reduction without spending much, nothing beats it.

Best for

Waterdrop Faucet F

Households tired of replacing filters constantly: a long-life cartridge and strong flow rate mean fewer changes and less faucet sputter.

PUR PLUS Faucet Mo

Most households on city water who want certified lead and chlorine reduction at the tap without plumbing or a pitcher to refill.

Culligan FM-25 Fau

Budget buyers who still want certified lead reduction: the cheapest filter here that keeps NSF/ANSI 53 lead certification rather than dropping to taste-only.

Avoid if

Waterdrop Faucet F

You need certified lead or heavy-contaminant reduction — Waterdrop's faucet filter is certified for fewer contaminants, so lead-focused buyers should choose the PUR PLUS or Culligan.

PUR PLUS Faucet Mo

You have a pull-down, pull-out, or non-standard faucet — clip-on filters won't fit, and an under-sink system is the better path.

Culligan FM-25 Fau

You push a lot of water daily — its cartridge life is shorter than the Waterdrop's, so heavy users may pay more per year despite the low sticker price.

Score breakdown

fit

Waterdrop

8.7

PUR PLUS F

9.4

Culligan F

8.6

ease

Waterdrop

9.0

PUR PLUS F

9.2

Culligan F

8.8

value

Waterdrop

8.8

PUR PLUS F

9.1

Culligan F

9.3

quality

Waterdrop

8.5

PUR PLUS F

9.2

Culligan F

8.4

Specs

flow

Fast ~0.5 GPM rated (among quickest in lab tests)

—

Slow (~0.5 GPM)

type

Faucet-mount filter (standard faucets)

media

Activated carbon fiber (ACF), 0.5 micron

Mineral Core (carbon + ion exchange + minerals)

—

price

~$30

~$35

~$25

install

Tool-free; on/off switch; not for pull-out/spray/touchless

Tool-free; on/off diverter; not for pull-out/touchless

Tool-free; auto-reset diverter; not for pull-out/spray

lead note

NOT NSF 53 lead-removal certified (lead claims are lab-tested only)

—

filter life

320 gallons / ~3 months (~2x most)

~100 gallons / ~2-3 months

~200 gallons / ~2 months (FM-25R cartridge)

certifications

NSF/ANSI 42 (chlorine/taste) + 372 (lead-free material)

NSF/ANSI 42 (taste) + 53 (lead); horizontal adds 401

NSF/ANSI 42 (taste) + 53 (lead, mercury, cysts)

reduces

—

~70 substances: lead, mercury, chlorine, microplastics, some pesticides

Chlorine, lead, mercury, cysts (giardia/crypto), turbidity, atrazine, lindane

indicator

—

Filter-change light

—

build

—

Chrome-plated plastic; 2-yr warranty; no indicator light

Buy →Buy →Buy →

	Waterdrop Faucet Filter	PUR PLUS Faucet Mount Filter	Culligan FM-25 Faucet Filter
Score	8.7	9.4	8.6
Price	$30	$35	$25
Verdict	The long-life pick. A 320-gallon cartridge lasts about twice as long as most, with among the fastest flow tested and excellent taste reduction. One caveat: it's NSF 42 certified but NOT NSF 53 for lead, so if lead is your concern pick the PUR or Culligan instead.	The safe all-rounder. Most clip-ons only handle taste, but the PUR PLUS is also certified for lead under NSF 53 and clips on tool-free. Cartridges last only 2-3 months and it won't fit pull-down faucets, but for certified taste-and-lead at the tap, it's the default.	The budget pick that keeps the cert. The cheapest filter here still NSF 53 certified for lead, plus mercury and even cysts like giardia that most faucet filters miss. Flow is slow and there's no indicator, but for certified lead reduction without spending much, nothing beats it.
Best for	Households tired of replacing filters constantly: a long-life cartridge and strong flow rate mean fewer changes and less faucet sputter.	Most households on city water who want certified lead and chlorine reduction at the tap without plumbing or a pitcher to refill.	Budget buyers who still want certified lead reduction: the cheapest filter here that keeps NSF/ANSI 53 lead certification rather than dropping to taste-only.
Avoid if	You need certified lead or heavy-contaminant reduction — Waterdrop's faucet filter is certified for fewer contaminants, so lead-focused buyers should choose the PUR PLUS or Culligan.	You have a pull-down, pull-out, or non-standard faucet — clip-on filters won't fit, and an under-sink system is the better path.	You push a lot of water daily — its cartridge life is shorter than the Waterdrop's, so heavy users may pay more per year despite the low sticker price.
Score breakdown
fit	8.7	9.4	8.6
ease	9.0	9.2	8.8
value	8.8	9.1	9.3
quality	8.5	9.2	8.4
Specs
flow	Fast ~0.5 GPM rated (among quickest in lab tests)	—	Slow (~0.5 GPM)
type	Faucet-mount filter (standard faucets)	Faucet-mount filter (standard faucets)	Faucet-mount filter (standard faucets)
media	Activated carbon fiber (ACF), 0.5 micron	Mineral Core (carbon + ion exchange + minerals)	—
price	~$30	~$35	~$25
install	Tool-free; on/off switch; not for pull-out/spray/touchless	Tool-free; on/off diverter; not for pull-out/touchless	Tool-free; auto-reset diverter; not for pull-out/spray
lead note	NOT NSF 53 lead-removal certified (lead claims are lab-tested only)	—	—
filter life	320 gallons / ~3 months (~2x most)	~100 gallons / ~2-3 months	~200 gallons / ~2 months (FM-25R cartridge)
certifications	NSF/ANSI 42 (chlorine/taste) + 372 (lead-free material)	NSF/ANSI 42 (taste) + 53 (lead); horizontal adds 401	NSF/ANSI 42 (taste) + 53 (lead, mercury, cysts)
reduces	—	~70 substances: lead, mercury, chlorine, microplastics, some pesticides	Chlorine, lead, mercury, cysts (giardia/crypto), turbidity, atrazine, lindane
indicator	—	Filter-change light	—
build	—	—	Chrome-plated plastic; 2-yr warranty; no indicator light
	Buy →	Buy →	Buy →

PickGrade may earn a commission from purchases made through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. This never affects our grades. Full disclosure.