Head-to-head
Midea U+ vs Windmill WhisperTech: Engineering vs Ease
These two are the strongest cases for opposite philosophies of the quiet window AC. Midea's U+ bends the chassis around the window sash so the compressor hums outside a closed pane — the reason it's the quietest unit in independent lab testing and the reason installing it involves a saddle bracket and more patience than most. Windmill took the other route: a conventional shape re-engineered for humans, shipped pre-assembled with the mounting kit in the box, installable by one person in about half an hour, and styled like something you'd choose to look at. The spec sheets say they're twins — 8,000 BTU, inverter compressors, roughly 42 dB, smart apps, Energy Star. The lived difference is in the details the box doesn't print: TechGearLab measured the Midea pulling a test room down 8.6°F in an hour, among the fastest of any 8K unit, while the Windmill cooled noticeably slower in the same lab. The Midea's U-design also lets you keep opening the window all season. The Windmill counters with the install, the looks, and a small but real smart-home edge. At $349.99 vs $429, the Midea is also the cheaper machine — this one comes down to which friction you'd rather live with.
 Midea U+ Smart Inverter Window AC (8,000 BTU, MAW08U1QWT) Midea |  Windmill WhisperTech Smart Window AC (8,000 BTU) Windmill | |
|---|---|---|
| Score | 8.9 | 8.4 |
| Price | $349.99 | $429 |
| Verdict | Inverter quiet, class-leading efficiency, and a window that still opens make it the default for bedrooms up to 350 sq ft. The catches: a fussier bracket install than a drop-in unit, and buy it new — only post-recall units carry the redesigned drainage. | A pre-assembled kit, a 42 dB inverter, and a front panel you won't apologize for — Windmill wins on install speed, looks, and app polish. You trade a slower initial cooldown and a design premium; if peak efficiency per dollar is the goal, the Midea and LG beat it. |
| Best for | you want the quietest, cheapest-to-run bedroom AC and don't mind a more involved one-time install | your AC lives in plain sight in a studio or living room and you want the easiest possible install |
| Avoid if | you need to cool more than 350 sq ft, or you're tempted by a used pre-recall U on the secondhand market | you're optimizing cooling speed or efficiency per dollar — the Midea U+ and LG do more for less |
| Score breakdown | ||
| value | 9.0 | 7.6 |
| quietness | 9.7 | 9.3 |
| cooling power | 8.0 | 7.6 |
| smart features | 8.5 | 8.7 |
| installation fit | 7.5 | 9.5 |
| energy efficiency | 9.5 | 8.3 |
| Specs | ||
| model | MAW08U1QWT (post-recall U+ design) | 08W2Wi (WhisperTech) |
| weight | ~54 lb | — |
| warranty | 1 year | 1 year |
| compressor | Variable-speed DC inverter | Variable-speed inverter with linear fan |
| dimensions | 21.97 x 19.17 x 13.46 in | — |
| noise level | As low as 32 dBA (ultra-quiet inverter operation) | From 42 dB (WhisperTech inverter) |
| window type | Single/double-hung; window remains operable after install | — |
| room coverage | Up to 350 sq ft | Up to 350 sq ft |
| smart control | Midea SmartHome app, Alexa, Google Assistant, Apple Watch | Windmill app, Alexa, Google Assistant |
| cooling capacity | 8,000 BTU (DOE) | 8,000 BTU |
| energy certification | Energy Star | Energy Star; up to 15.0 CEER |
| claimed energy savings | Up to 35% vs federal standard | — |
| airflow | — | 45° upward vent with dual front-and-bottom intake |
| filtration | — | Washable antimicrobial mesh + optional activated carbon filter |
| window fit | — | 23–37 in wide, min 14 in opening height (single/double-hung) |
| install kit | — | Pre-assembled in box |
| Buy → | Buy → | |
Final verdict
The Midea wins on the fundamentals: it cools faster in lab testing, holds a lower noise floor, and costs $80 less. If the AC's job is to disappear — acoustically and financially — it's the pick, and the U-channel means your window still opens. The Windmill wins the parts of the experience Midea doesn't compete in: it's in the window in half an hour without a helper, it looks like furniture instead of machinery, and its app and auto mode are more polished. Buy the Midea for the engineering; buy the Windmill if install effort or aesthetics is the thing you'll actually notice every day. Renters with a move on the horizon should weight the Windmill's easy in-and-out more heavily than the spec sheet suggests.
PickGrade may earn a commission from purchases made through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. This never affects our grades. Full disclosure.